Don't be shellfish...Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on Reddit

1390682518000-ball-1-26-14

I only hold hands when I hold balls. Totally makes sense.

It has been pointed out that in my 2014 Fantasy Football Rankings, Montee Ball ranks quite lower than that of my peers. And while my first argument for this would be: gravity, bro (get it?), there are still many question marks here that prevent me from fully believing, kind of like Scientology. But less-less crazy and with more of Peyton Manning‘s forehead. And, sure, it’s easy to point out that the Broncos offense remains elite from last season’s historic run, which certainly played a large role in Knowshon Moreno‘s gaudy totals. And it should be noted, in that environment, Ball was able to average 4.7 yards-per-carry for the season (5.9 YPG in the final two months). But there are some things still holding me back. But don’t worry, I’m still the big spoon in this scenario. We can all rest easy friends.

Before I tell you why he’s overrated, I should preface this by saying that I think he’s a very talented back, and has the potential to fill a RB1 role on any fantasy team. But as of this moment, the price tag appears to be a top-15, and in some cases, a top-10 overall draft selection. We’re talking about a back, even with the impressive YPG numbers mentioned above, that has 120 carries and 559 yards as his only body of work in the National Football League. Add to that; he didn’t help himself with three fumbles in those 120 carries, also combined with his suspect pass protection. To be fair, these issues seemed to be improved upon as the season progressed, but for a veteran-friendly coach like John Fox, there would be zero hesitation in ceding carries to C.J. Anderson and company if these problems rear their head again. Why they’ve actually manifested a head is anyone’s guess and sounds like the beginning of a strange horror movie. Or one hell of a digression.

Yes, he’s probably a good player who is part of a really good offense, and that should be reason enough to want him on your team. I’m not going to argue that. But the same things I said about why Tre Mason was overrated rings true here as well. Ball control and pass protection, while not really things fantasy football attributes points to, are an integral part of a running back’s game, and those who have shown weakness in these areas early in their careers, no matter the promise, always gives me pause. Let’s not forget about Ryan Mathews, who also had these same issues, and it took him three seasons to emerge into last year’s career breakout. It may be an apples/oranges comparison because of the injuries Mathews suffered, probably slowing his development, but it can’t be denied that there were specific game-plan decisions from 2010-2012 based on his weaknesses. And I’m sure there was a fruit basket involved somewhere. Needs more mango if you ask me. And may I add that these years also led to the amazing discovery that Ronnie Brown was actually still alive. Who knew?

Montee Ball is eminently draftable… but in the 1st or 2nd round? No, I don’t think there’s enough body of work to justify that, not to mention the risk I’ve mentioned. 3rd round? Yeah, that feels right to me, but no one is going to be able to land him at that price, which makes him dun-dun-DUUUN!… overrated. TITLE TIE-IN ALERT: CONDITION AWESOME!

  1. the_hungary_hippo says:
    (link)

    Pretty Standard 14-team Yahoo league with .25 PPR

    Teams select draft slots… picks 1-4, 10 and 11 are taken.

    What slot would you settle in and call home?

    Thanks

    • Jay

      Jay says:
      (link)

      @the_hungary_hippo: I think I answered this in the other thread, but just in case, I’d want the 6th or 7th spot.

  2. psmith says:
    (link)

    Would you keep Spiller in the 9th round or Ball in the 10th?

    • Jay

      Jay says:
      (link)

      I’m still on the Spiller bandwagon.

  3. Rowdy Piper says:
    (link)

    Keep 3 Auction ($200 cap)
    Cobb – 11
    Alshon – 12
    Ball – 5
    Peyton – 25

    • Jay

      Jay says:
      (link)

      You almost have to keep ball here. I’d go Cobb and Alson as well.

  4. My Minor Likes Female Pujols says:
    (link)

    Nice article! Agree on ball. While we’re on the RB topic I have a keeper/dynasty question.
    Going to use my waiver on a rb to stash, who would you go after in dynasty league?

    James White (sweet feet)- great camp so far, could be “the guy” next season if both rb leave in New England.

    Charles Sims TB- Martin in rbbc? I don’t think a team drafts a rb without intention of using him.

    Lagarrete Blount- Bell handcuff at most but he’s not old

    Dex Mccluster- Woodhead put up big points with same coach in SD and now Mccluster will be the Woodhead of TEN

    Or go WR for Brian Quick, John Brown

    Thanks for reading! Sorry about the length

    • Jay

      Jay says:
      (link)

      @My Minor Likes Female Pujols: no worries at all, and thanks! Spoiler alert, there will be a sleeper post coming out on McCluster soon!

  5. Anthony says:
    (link)

    14 Team keeper league with lots of RBs kept. Keep 2 of 3:

    —Ball in 2
    —Newton in 7
    —Cobb in 8

    • Jay

      Jay says:
      (link)

      Newton, Cobb. 2nd seems really steep.

Comments are closed.